What the Editors Want, Part 2

So what do editors want?

There isn’t any simple answer, because the things that take a book from the slush pile to publication are mostly ephemeral qualities. Most editors really only know what they want when they see it. And any attempts to narrow it down (“What I really want is a gothic vampire action adventure romance”) are more likely to lead to frustration than a book sale. It’s a lot like dating, actually.

You may think you want a certain type of guy. You look for Him. He’s handsome, medium build, blond, blue-eyed, works in finance, and has a great sense of humor and is forceful without being a jerk and sensitive without being a weeny and he never, ever forgets your birthday or your anniversary and always, always knows exactly what you want for Christmas. Also he’s great in bed and preferably is a great Trivial Pursuit player, but you’re a little flexible on this last quality because you can teach him. Trivial Pursuit, that is.

Looking for That Guy is going to leave you wildly frustrated. And what about all the other cool but not That Guy guys out there? You miss out on them.

It’s the same with publishing. If an editor is looking too hard for a certain type of book, she’ll be in danger of overlooking some other wonderful book, so she isn’t likely to look too hard for any certain type of book. And if you try too hard to write the exact book you think your targetted editor is looking for, you’re likely to miss out on what you do well.

And what is that? You have to figure it out by trial and error. You have to listen to feedback from critique partners and editors and contest judges, and you have to decide what feedback you agree with. You have to hone your gut sense about your work by getting it in front of any audience you can and then seeing their reaction. It can take years, but the years are going to pass anyway, so you might as well spend them doing something you love.

And you do love writing, don’t you? Because that’s the only reason to do it. If you love it as much as you love breathing (and by love, I don’t mean you actually enjoy sitting down at the computer every day–I mean that you can’t not write, because not writing would feel a little like death), and if you keep working at it, keep trying to get better, you’ll have the most important reward you can have as a writer.

No, I don’t mean getting published. Though that is a lovely reward. I mean, you’ll know you’ve done your best. And if you’ve done your best, and you’re writing books you love, chances are an editor will recognize it. And she’ll have to have you as her author.

The simple and complicated truth is, editors want great books. They want beautifully written books. They want books they can’t put down. And a beautifully written, can’t-put-downable book is inside you, waiting to get out onto the page. So what are you doing here? Go write it!


  1. I’ve spent a couple of days thinking about this. It’s an interesting dilemma b/c writing what you love may lead you away from the line you like, but in the end, you own your career, and you own your writing. Writing a beautifully-written, can’t-put-downable book is a huge accomplishment – my ultimate dream, anyway – and it’s SO easy to lose in the fervor to publish. This is especially true for lines, where there’s a specific feel to the books (some more specific than others).

    I feel pretty lucky that so far I’ve written what I wanted to write, and submitted it to an editor I really, really want to work with. I hope it works out, but as I’ve KEPT writing in the waiting time I know the next time I submit something, it will be stronger. That’s a good feeling, too!

  2. Very wise thoughts, Anne. It really easy to lose sight of that beautifully written book goal. On the other hand, do keep in mind that my blog posts tend to be rather unplanned, shoot-from-the-hip thoughts, 🙂 and it occurs to me now how valuable it is to write anything–everything–just write, and not get *too* caught up in writing the best thing ever. At times I’ve discovered really important things about myself as a writer, by writing to market needs. These are things I may or may not have discovered otherwise, so I can’t discount the value of just being a productive writer.

    Which, it sounds like, you very much are!

  3. Oh, I couldn’t agree more, Jamie! Harlequin’s been around a looooong time because they’ve figured out what readers want, and they work to supply it. Learning to meet those demands, IMHO, is another tool in your kit, one you can apply to your stories. I mean…we’re not writing literary fiction here. It’s market-driven…and up to us to decide how tightly we want to fit that marketing. Getting paid to write feels pretty good, too! 😉

    Thanks for the great posts! I enjoy shoot from the hip as much as carefully planned!

  4. My, what a busy day! Love those cute shoes, cute shoes really can bteghrin an entire day 🙂 You are very fortunate to have such a handy husband. They all have their gifts, don’t they, but the handy ones are sure convenient (not to mention a $$ saver!)

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: